Higher Education – Caught Between Dystopia and Utopia, And The Way Out!


Higher Education – Caught between Dystopia and Utopia. And the Way Out!

Every time we redefine higher education, we confine it between the extremes – the old and the new. But now it’s ready to break away from the box.

No matter how we envision the future of higher education, we fundamentally limit it to our own points of view. More often, we oscillate between the two extremes – technology fixing the age-old education system and technology plotting to destroy education.

What Proponents Say?

The actual impact of technology on education is a bone of contention. Proponents consider it to be the perfect solution for disrupting pre-historic higher education system, supposedly offering just-in-time, high-quality, skill-based education at a fraction of the cost of traditional instruction.

How? The professors capture their wisdom and expertise in video lessons and make them available on mobile devices of the learners ready to be consumed just when they want to gain knowledge.

Not only this, elearning has the capability to disrupt the entire scenario – in terms of – price, location, access to material, and even pedagogy. Tech supporters also believe that “the end of college” has just begun. Not to say, they are closed eyes to elearning inefficiencies - precisely - lack of human interaction and hands-on learning.

Probably this is why there’s a big question mark on the completion rate of MOOCs. Real human interaction - the most crucial component of quality learning – is still missing. The extremely low completion rate shows that university education cannot be replaced with self-instruction. The latter not only limits one’s ability to be thorough with the subject but is also highly ineffective.

But looking through a different lens, the growing fascination with elearning has the power to bring one potentially big change. The higher ed institutions may be compelled to provide quality education via different means to suit learners world over.

What Opponents Say?

Elearning can never replace university education. Reports on MOOC engagement have confirmed it. Not only has higher education a crucial role to play in meeting civic needs, it’s the foolproof pathway to the most lucrative employment opportunities. And it’s still a prerequisite for white- collar jobs across the world.

Elearning can never be as worthy and impactful as traditional instruction. Perhaps self-direction is the most destructive aspect of online learning. Opponents believe in it so much so that it has become a cliché to say “technology is ruining classrooms”.

However, there’s a flaw in this outlook.

Learners are in desperate need for an education – which is valuable, engaging and inexpensive, and independent of location. And only technology can make it possible. The latest valuation of elearning industry ($100 billion in 2015) confirms it.

There’s a tendency for institutional leaders to discourage any kind of innovation that has the ability to disrupt four-year high-priced higher education model. When students’ debt is mounting high and learners questioning the value of a college degree, the tech opponents hope that the inefficiencies of traditional university education will magically disappear.

The Way Out!

Neither the complete automation nor sticking to traditional instruction can fix education. Period.

Whether the advancement in edtech will end college or not – is a question that time will answer. What matters more, at the moment, is – how to make higher education more valuable, easily accessible and economical for learners from across the world. The need is to reinvent university.

Till now, we have seen two ways to deliver learning – offline and online. Neither of these has been fully successful in isolation.

What does this mean? An amalgamation of technology and real-time instruction will be ideal to deliver low-cost yet valuable education. The way edtech can improve the entire learning process needs to be appreciated. It is insanely good at providing access to the best learning material from the best universities, created and curated by the best educators. Also, fostering real-time instruction and interaction.

Technology addresses three main pain points – cost, access and geographical location. Live lecturing keeps the social component of traditional classrooms intact while pre-recorded sessions deliver learning 24/7.  

However, it’s important to remember – integration of technology in bits and pieces doesn’t help. A deeper incorporation is required. Sure, experiments fail. Speed bumps slow down the pace. But what is important to make it work is to – iterate. Iterate until you strike the right balance. 

About the Author
Author: Shivani SharmaWebsite: http://www.wiziq.com
Shivani is currently Content Manager at WizIQ, a leading online learning platform. She's written on various subjects, including education, technology and learning management. She loves to keep up on the latest trends in elearning industry.

Like what we do?

The Latest EdTech News To Your Inbox

Follow us:

   

   

 

Latest EdTech News To Your Inbox

 

The EdTech Tweets

EdTechReview RT @DrDhrajMehrotra: “Quality Education” The Ultimate Desire by Parents! - EdTechReview™ (ETR) https://t.co/Be2K4SKw34
About 7 hours ago
EdTechReview Do you know, What parents would be expecting from schools in India this year https://t.co/uIJlwknngC edtechchat education edapps ptchat
About 9 hours ago

Follow etr_in on Twitter
BLOG COMMENTS POWERED BY DISQUS

News | Data & Statistics

Research, Reviews & Dictionary

  • Latest

  • Popular

Trends & Insights

EdTech Voices

e-Learning

Events

About ETR Community

EdTechReview (ETR) is a community of and for everyone involved in education technology to connect and collaborate both online and offline to discover, learn, utilize and share about the best ways technology can improve learning, teaching, and leading in the 21st century.

EdTechReview spreads awareness on education technology and its role in 21st century education through best research and practices of using technology in education, and by facilitating events, training, professional development, and consultation in its adoption and implementation.

 

-> Read More

Join The Community

Subscribe and Join the 21,000+ members who trust us...

Testimonials
I find every news, reviews very informative and interesting. This site is indeed a great site for both teachers and learners. Thanks to EdTech for creating such an enriching site on education. Hats off!!
- Regin Brown, Educationist and Blogger, United Kingdom


My group likes this site because it's so up-to-date and has tons of relevant articles.
- Angela Giuliano, Teacher, New Mexico


Your write ups and articles ignites the minds making them receptive to the whole new wealth of EdTech.
- Jagat Rana, Parent, India


EdTechReview has some great resources for teachers who need to get some ideas about technology in the classroom.
- Loretta Wideman,Teacher, East Africa


EdTechReview keeps educators up to date with trending tech savvy terms relative to the discipline.
- Dr. Ingrid Rizzolo,Education Professional, Curriculum and Instruction Designer, New York City Area

-> Read More

Go to Our Network List

Core of Education EdTechDigest EmergingEdTech The Chronicle  Inside Higher Ed  Edutopia EyeOnEducation Eye On Education Classroomaid Classroomaid